It's no question that I'm a music nerd and is what will always keep me going . Now, I know what you're thinking ? There's got to be a band or a certain artists that he can''t be fond of? The answer might surprise you but it's a fact. I have had my fair share of bands that I didn't like at all (at first). I didn't care for U2 for the longest time. I had no problem with the Edge and the other band members (though I admit now that in my opinion the edge isn't the most groundbreaking guitarist) Nope. My problem was with Bono. I thought he was preachy and full of himself .It was also because I was so used to FM rock radio playing the same hits over and over and over. But then I realized something . If I can love Bruce Springsteen even though he can be political; then why couldn't I give a liking to U2? Once I discovered their first LP Boy and dug deeper into 1983's War, I swung in the other direction .
Now you're probably asking yourself "What does U2 have to do with this R.E.M. hot take?" Well, I'll tell you. I've listened to a boatload of bands and artists in my life and I can honestly say that R.E.M. just doesn't cut it for me. The first part of my disliking can come from the constant radio play of their most popular tunes. If I had a nickle for every time I heard "Losing My Religion" "Everybody Hurts " "It's the end of the world as we know it (and I feel fine) , I would be a millionaire . Now just like U2, I wanted to give the same treatment to R.E.M. so like any good music nerd, I started from the beginning of their catalog.
Here's the hot take. The bands sound and their songwriting doesn't bother me. When R.E.M released their first LP in 1983 titled Murmur , the sound and production of the record was fairly common at the time for lots of new-wave rock acts. Another factor that doesn't bother me are guitarist Peter Buck and drummer Bill Berry. I find Bill Berry to be a solid drummer and Peter Buck is an extremely gifted and underrated guitarist whose playing reminds me of a combination of both James Honeymoon Scott and Johnny Marr. My problem and what makes the buck stop for me is lead singer Michael Stripe. I can't stand for the life of me his vocal approach. I find his vocal approach to be throbbing and whiny to no end . I just don't understand why a lead singer can sound the way he does with a band that clearly knows how to play their instruments. The song that can back up my opinion is their hit "The One I love" . Everything about the song musically sounds great .The track is polished and Peter Buck's guitar riff is killer while Berry lays a simple yet effective beat. Once again, Stripes vocals just turn me off completely.
That's my hot take on Alt rock superstars R.E.M. I might be coming off as a Lester Bangs or Robert Christgau but just like them, I have my own crazy opinions.